Every extra approver makes your campaign look more like your competitor's
Each approver removes a piece of whatever bothers them, and what's left is a version that would fit any brand. See how to set who decides and write the criteria before the piece exists.

In a marketing approval process with too many approvers, each person cuts the part that bothers them. After five rounds, what's left is the version that bothers nobody, and that version would work for any competitor. The fix has two parts: one person decides each type of piece while the others are consulted or informed, and the approval criteria are written into the brief before the piece exists.
How committee approval erases what makes the brand different
Each approver removes what bothers them, and what bothers them is often exactly what sets the piece apart. Legal softens the promise, sales removes the number it finds risky, leadership tones down the voice and product adds one more feature to the list. Each cut makes sense on its own. Together, they leave the campaign lukewarm.
The cost shows up in the schedule too. Every extra round pushes the date back, swells the marketing request queue and feeds marketing rework, which starts before production.
Who decides in the marketing approval process
One person decides each type of piece, and the others give input or simply stay informed. In its RAPID method, Bain & Company recommends that the decide role ideally sits with a single person per decision. People who provide input are heard, without their opinion having to be adopted.
A simple table settles who approves what:
| Piece | Decides | Consulted | Informed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Social media post | marketing coordinator | whoever knows the topic | sales |
| Ad | marketing coordinator | sales; legal, if there's a promise | leadership |
| Landing page | marketing coordinator | product and sales | leadership |
| Launch campaign | marketing manager or director | product, sales and legal | whole team |
In the marketing approval process, consulted people speak at the start, while the brief is still open. Feedback that arrives with the finished piece becomes a suggestion for the next one, unless the piece fails the criteria.
The approval criteria go into the brief
A piece is approved on what it needs to prove, and that's written down before it exists. The brief includes:
- the objective and the action you expect from whoever sees the piece;
- the message that has to land, in one sentence;
- the proof behind the message: a number, a case study, an approved testimonial;
- what doesn't change, such as the tone and the main promise;
- what's up to the team, such as the image and the order of elements.
With that, the question for approvers shifts from “do you like it?” to “does the piece meet the criteria?”. It helps to have a brief with approval criteria for each type of piece and a creative approval workflow that shows which stage each one is in.
A limit on rounds, and what to do when it's exceeded
One agreed round of changes, with everyone's comments in one place, covers most requests. Trouble starts when it's exceeded. Three rules help:
- The criteria changed? It becomes a new request, with a new deadline.
- Consulted people disagree? The decider chooses, and the piece moves on.
- An approver showed up who wasn't on the table? For this piece, they're informed, and their role goes into the next review of the table.
The swap test as the final filter
Before publishing, swap your brand's name for a competitor's and read it again. If the piece still makes sense, the approvals ate the difference. Go back to the criteria and give the piece back what was cut for no reason. It's the same swap test that applies to brand copy.
In our launch campaigns, the objective, the audience and the concept are set before the first piece, and every creative is born inside that concept.
Frequently asked questions
How many people should approve a marketing piece?
One decides. The others are consulted in the brief or informed afterwards. When more than one person has to have the final word, agree beforehand on how the decision gets made.
How do I set up a marketing approval process?
List the types of pieces, define who decides, who is consulted and who is informed for each one, write the approval criteria into the brief and agree on how many rounds of changes fit the deadline.





