Mtools

Content

Strategy

The persona your team loves is often the one that buys the least

A workshop persona describes the customer the team wishes it had. See the signs of an invented persona and how to rebuild it with the people who bought and the ones who walked away.

A frosted glass 3D photo frame with a red heart glowing inside, at the center of the frame, on a black background

The marketing persona that's born in a workshop, gets a name and a photo and is never opened again describes the customer the team wishes it had. It's built from what everyone already believes, so it goes down well in the meeting and guides very little afterwards. To be useful, a persona has to come from the people who actually bought and the ones who walked away: CRM data first, then short interviews, and a simple proof that it works, the decisions it changed.

A quick test tells you whether this is your case. Pull the customers you closed in the last 12 months and count how many match the persona on the poster. If it's only a few, the team is writing for someone who buys less than it seems.

The signs of an invented marketing persona

You can spot an invented persona by the absence of real customer data. Nielsen Norman Group calls this kind of persona a proto-persona, created in a workshop with no new research, and warns that it's often an inaccurate picture of users and can become an echo chamber for the team's wrong assumptions.

The most common signs:

  • all the personas look alike, with the same age, the same role and the same routine;
  • the pains are generic, like “not enough time” or “wants to grow”, and would fit any competitor's customer;
  • no field comes from the CRM: industry, company size, role of whoever signed, deal length;
  • nobody checks the document to decide on content, media or a page on the site;
  • the name and photo take up more space than the buying objections.

The second sign is the same problem as the swap test for brand copy: if the description would fit any company in the industry, it doesn't help yours choose anything.

Persona and company profile answer different questions

The company profile describes the account, and the persona describes the people inside it. The profile covers industry, size, region and business stage. The persona covers the role, what that person is measured on, what they fear and where they look for information.

In complex sales, the purchase goes through several people: whoever will use it, whoever decides, finance, legal, IT. A single marketing persona covers one seat at that table. That's why it makes sense to have one persona per role in the decision, tied to the map of the buying committee sales already sees in each deal.

What to pull from the CRM before the interviews

The CRM shows who bought and who walked away, and that's your list of who to interview. Before booking any conversation, pull:

  • deals won in the last year, with the role of whoever came in first and whoever signed;
  • industry, size and lead source for each one;
  • time from first contact to close;
  • deals lost with the reason recorded, which show the objections the poster persona ignores;
  • the sales rep's notes, where the repeated questions show up.

The loss reasons in your CRM are the part a workshop persona leaves out. The people who walked away explain what your communication didn't answer.

A short customer interview guide

Short conversations with recent customers and with lost deals are worth more than any workshop. For qualitative personas, Nielsen Norman Group recommends interviewing 5 to 30 people, stopping when new conversations bring little that's new. Ask permission to record and write down each person's exact words.

For those who bought

  1. What was going on at the company when you started looking for a solution?
  2. Who else took part in the decision and what did each person need to see?
  3. Where did you look for information before talking to us?
  4. What other options did you consider and why did you go with this one?
  5. What almost made you give up?
  6. How would you explain the problem to a peer at another company?

For those who walked away

  1. What weighed on the decision not to move forward or to choose another company?
  2. At what point did the conversation lose momentum?
  3. What would have changed the decision?

The answers to question six become ad, post and page headlines, because they're in your buyers' own words. In our marketing planning, the persona comes from the company's customer base: who buys, what they need and the sales objections.

Talk to usWant help planning this at your company?Tell us what you need. We'll reply by email or WhatsApp and, if it makes sense, put together a quote.Contact us

How to know whether the new persona works

A persona works when it changes decisions. If the new document leaves content, media and the site exactly as they were, it repeated the old one with a different photo.

Three months after it's done, list the decisions it changed:

  • content, with topics taken from the pains and words in the interviews;
  • media, with targeting by the role and industry of real customers;
  • the site, with a page or a section for each role in the decision;
  • sales, with the approach adjusted to the objections from lost deals.

Also track the share of leads with the persona's role and industry, and how many of them become opportunities. If that share grows, your communication is talking to the people who buy. The same cross-check helps you score leads by profile when the team rolls out lead scoring. Redo the interviews once a year, or sooner if the product shifts to a new audience.

Frequently asked questions

What is a marketing persona?

A description of a person involved in the purchase, built from real customers: role, goals, pains, objections and where they look for information. It guides content, media, the site and the sales approach.

How many personas does a company need?

One for each role that carries weight in the buying decision. In complex sales, that usually includes whoever uses the product, whoever decides and whoever approves the budget.

What's the difference between a persona and a target audience?

The target audience is a broad slice, such as industry, size and region. The persona puts a face on one person inside that slice, with what they need to hear in order to buy.

Share

shall we createsomething together?

related content