Mtools

Content

Sales

Your biggest competitor is the customer who decides not to decide

Many deals that disappear didn't go to a competitor: they stopped because the buyer was afraid of getting it wrong. See how to read this in the CRM and what content reduces the risk of buying.

A frosted glass 3D traffic light with the top light glowing red inside, on a black background

When sales says the customer “went quiet” or the purchase “got pushed to next year”, a stalled deal almost never went to a competitor. The buyer was afraid of getting it wrong and chose not to decide. Matt Dixon, co-author of The JOLT Effect (2022, with Ted McKenna), said in an interview with CustomerThink that, in their research, between 40% and 60% of all deals were lost to the customer doing nothing.

The figure comes from an analysis of about 2.5 million recorded sales conversations, from simpler transactional sales to complex solution sales. If your company sells with long cycles and several people in the decision, indecision is the opponent that shows up most in your funnel. Marketing usually aims at the wrong target: it produces content to prove the product is good, when what holds up the signature is the risk of the choice going wrong.

Losing to a competitor or losing to indecision

A loss to a competitor has a reason and a date; a loss to indecision drags on until someone closes the deal out in the CRM. A buyer who picked another vendor usually tells you: the other proposal was cheaper, the competitor's integration fit better, they went with someone they already knew. A buyer who never decided fades away.

In the CRM, the two cases leave different signals:

Signal Lost to a competitor Lost to indecision
Loss reason “went with another vendor”, with the competitor's name “revisit later”, “not a priority”, “no budget right now” or an empty field
Expected close date stays put until the “no” keeps getting pushed to next month
Time in stage similar to won deals far above the average for won deals
Last conversation the customer compares price and scope the customer asks for one more document, one more meeting, one more quote

Split the two in your report. A “no decision” option in the list of loss reasons shows the size of the problem within a few months. When we gathered the loss reasons of one of our clients, a technology company, “revisit the conversation later” was among the reasons on the list. Using CRM loss reasons as your content plan starts with this split, because each reason calls for different content.

What Dixon and McKenna found in sales conversations

Indecision comes more from the fear of making a mistake than from attachment to the current way of working. The usual explanation for a stalled deal is the status quo: the customer thinks what they have today is good enough, and the seller didn't show the cost of staying put. In the interview, Dixon says preference for the status quo accounts for less than half of the losses to no decision.

The larger share comes from buyers who already accept they need to change and still don't sign. They are afraid of making a big mistake. Dixon explains this through omission bias: people prefer the error of doing nothing to the error of doing something that goes wrong, because nobody wants to be the one responsible for the choice.

Inside a company, that fear has a face. Think of the manager who championed a new vendor in front of leadership: if the rollout slips, the problem carries their name.

The book sums up what top-performing sellers do with this buyer in four behaviors, which spell the title:

  1. judge the level of indecision, to qualify and forecast the deal by the customer's ability to decide;
  2. offer a personal recommendation, instead of leaving the buyer alone with every option;
  3. limit the exploration, closing off searches that only eat up time (Dixon talks about analysis paralysis);
  4. take risk off the table, with ways to reduce perceived risk and build momentum toward a decision.

The last three depend on content. That is where marketing comes in.

Why more product arguments won't unstick a stalled deal

More product arguments give an indecisive buyer more to evaluate, and the decision gets heavier. They are already convinced the product is good. Their doubt is a different one: whether the company will manage to implement it, whether the team will use it, whether the promised result will show up and who answers for it if it doesn't.

When marketing answers that doubt with one more feature comparison, one more webinar on functionality or one more list of differentiators, it feeds the paralysis Dixon describes. Every new option is one more choice, and every extra choice is a new way to get it wrong.

Fear doesn't work as a push either. In the same interview, Dixon says that using fear to scare the customer into action usually backfires, because it gives them more to worry about. For someone already afraid of getting it wrong, the urgent discount email just adds one more worry to the list.

Content that reduces the risk of buying

The content that unlocks the decision shows how the purchase will work out, step by step, in the buyer's own reality. It answers fear with concrete detail. Four formats do this job.

The implementation plan

A document with the stages, the owners on both sides, the deadlines and what the customer needs to set aside in time and people. It replaces a vague promise (“we implement fast”) with a path the buyer can present inside the company. Experto has an implementation plan from kickoff to go-live that works as a starting point.

What happens in the first 90 days

The biggest fear lives at the beginning, when the money has gone out and the result hasn't arrived yet. A short piece covering what happens in the first, second and third month, with the deliverables and the first indicators of each phase, answers the question the buyer won't ask out loud: “how will I know, early on, that I chose right?”.

A case like theirs

The case study that reduces risk is the one about a company like the buyer's: same size, same kind of operation, the same obstacle at the start. Tell the process and what was hard, not only the result. The numbers need a source, and an inventory of numbers with a source keeps every piece from saying something different. It's the format of the case studies we publish here at Mtools: the challenge, the process and the result.

An answer for each person who decides

The person negotiating with the seller rarely decides alone. Finance wants to understand the contract and the exit, IT wants to know about security, leadership wants to know how long until the investment pays back. A piece for the people on the buying committee gives your contact what they need to defend the purchase in the meetings the seller doesn't attend.

Building this set together with sales, starting from the conversations that stalled, is part of our content marketing and SEO work: from mapping the objections to putting the material in the seller's hands.

Talk to usWant help planning this at your company?Tell us what you need. We'll reply by email or WhatsApp and, if it makes sense, put together a quote.Contact us

How to find out where your deals stall

The stage where a deal stalls points to the fear your content needs to answer, and sales is the team that knows it. Marketing has the CRM; sales has the conversations. One round of research brings the two together:

  1. Pull the deals from the last six months that were lost with no decision or have been open longer than the average won deal, with the stage where each one stopped.
  2. Count by stage. A deal stalled right after the proposal points to price or scope; at technical validation, to implementation; at signature, to whoever signs.
  3. Ask the sellers what the customer's last question was before going quiet. It usually points to the risk nobody answered.
  4. Listen to the recordings, if the team records its meetings, and write down the hesitation phrases: “I need to check with the team”, “let's wait for next quarter”, “what if it doesn't work?”.
  5. Pick one stage and one piece of content to start. Over the following months, compare the deals that got the material with the ones that didn't.

Lead behavior also offers clues before the first meeting: what a lead reads and how often they come back show who arrives with urgency and who arrives researching. Without that record, the sales process ends up deciding in the dark.

Repeat the conversation with sales once a month. After a quarter, the share of “no decision” losses shows whether the content made a difference.

Frequently asked questions

What should I do with a deal that has been stalled for months?

Ask your contact what has changed since the last conversation and offer a clear recommendation, with a small, low-risk next step, such as a pilot phase or a meeting with whoever signs. If nothing changes, record the loss as “no decision” so it enters the analysis.

How can I tell whether the customer is afraid of getting it wrong or has lost interest?

A customer who lost interest stops answering. A customer afraid of getting it wrong keeps answering, but asks for one more document, one more meeting or one more quote, and the close date keeps getting pushed.

What is marketing's role in a deal that stalled?

Producing what the seller can't improvise on the spot: the implementation plan, the first 90 days roadmap, the similar case and the answers for each person in the decision. The seller runs the conversation, and marketing delivers the material that takes risk off the table.

Share

shall we createsomething together?

related content